---
title: "@Yumina star rating system - World Discussions - Yumina Community"
description: "@yumina i think it would make sense to require users who leave a one-star review to provide a reason for their rating. Constructive feedback is important because it gives creators an opportunity to…"
url: https://yumina.io/app/community/thread/29bb7f40-b9b8-4369-ae6b-03d3d0312703
lang: en
---

[Community](https://yumina.io/app/community) · [World Discussions](https://yumina.io/app/community/world-discussions)

# @Yumina star rating system

[Kiesk](https://yumina.io/@kiesk) · 2026-10-25

@yumina i think it would make sense to require users who leave a one-star review to provide a reason for their rating. Constructive feedback is important because it gives creators an opportunity to understand what went wrong and potentially fix any issues with their work. When someone leaves a one-star review without explaining why, the creator is left guessing what the problem was or what they could improve. Requiring a brief explanation would encourage more meaningful reviews, help creators improve their work, and make the rating system fairer and more useful for everyone.

## 5 replies

1. [Yumina](https://yumina.io/@yumina) · Staff · 2026-10-25 Good point！We're considering you have to play a card before you can rate it and, 1-2 stars asks you to pick a quick reason (bug, AI quality, not as described, etc.), comment optional What does everyone think?
2. [Jon](https://yumina.io/@jon) · 2026-10-25 I agree playing a card before rating it would make sense. I think a pop up window for a 1-2 star rating asking "What didn't you like?" could be helpful. Then people could enter some text and it would either be posted as a review or a message to the creator. I agree with OP that constructive feedback is important.
3. [L](https://yumina.io/@ll4) · 2026-10-26 Makes sense, but if someone is going to write "Bug" and leave nothing else on it, then unless it's obvious, how are you going to find the bug, or how to improve the AI quality, so on and so forth.
4. [Kiesk](https://yumina.io/@kiesk) · 2026-10-26 And with what L said like some people might just say bug, so there can be a certain amount of words you would have to type instead of just saying one word and leaving the creator of the work more confused
5. [Kiesk](https://yumina.io/@kiesk) · 2026-10-26 Never mind I see now in the new update that exact thing so thank you @Yumina >\_&lt;
