Yumina

Community · Feedback

Suggestion: Requirement for reviewing worlds

Markyyy ·

I'm pretty new here but even I've noticed a pattern with reviews lately. A world gets a 1-star with something like "boring" or "didn't work for me" and when you check, the person clearly only sent like 2-3 messages before dropping it. Meanwhile the creator spent days building the thing.

I'm not saying negative reviews are bad. If a world is genuinely broken or the intro is a mess, people should be able to say that. But right now there's no difference between feedback from someone who actually played a world and someone who opened it, didn't vibe with the first message, and nuked the rating on the way out.

And honestly, the bigger issue is what this probably does to creators. Imagine pouring weeks into a world and watching it get tanked by a couple of ratings from people who played for 2 minutes. I'd just stop making stuff at that point, why bother? Some of the best worlds here clearly took serious passion to build, and it'd suck if the platform slowly bled its best creators because low-effort reviews kept burying good work.

My suggestion: put a small requirement before someone can leave a written review. Not hours played — that's easy to fake by just leaving it open — but something like a minimum of 15-20 messages sent in that world. That's low enough that anyone who gave it an honest try qualifies, but it filters out the drive-by stuff.

Anyone can still leave a star rating Written reviews need the message minimum Or just tag reviews with how much the person actually played ("played 5 min" vs "played 3 hours") so readers can judge for themselves

Honestly even just the tag alone would help a lot. Creators put real effort into these worlds and one lazy review can drag a good one down before it even gets discovered.

Curious if others have run into this or if it's just me.

10 replies

  1. 格鲁曼钢铁厂 ·

    设置门槛不见得合适,有些世界确实是刚玩就能发现有问题,但是加上实际游玩条目数我觉得是个好建议

  2. Markyyy ·

    You're actually right. But there are many new players that doesn't understand if it's really a bug or not so they just review it as a bad world without knowing if it's part of the function and mechanics or not

  3. 格鲁曼钢铁厂 ·

    确实。所以我觉得世界的创作者应该给玩家提供更详细一些的说明和引导,我看到很多世界都只有非常简略的说明,甚至根本没有说明,而当中的有些世界我玩了之后发现质量还不错,或者起码是合我的胃口的。毕竟一般来说,当我看到一个新的世界的时候,比起评论,我会优先看创作者自己的介绍,来决定我要不要尝试一下这个世界

  4. Yumina · Staff ·

    Agree with here, we will add this feature now

  5. 大大爆肝 ·

    问题是在游戏界面力留言也要评价,要么就是不评价也可以留言。

  6. giantfukker ·

    bro thats why I have reviews blocked because I already know the nature of people they just love bitchen for the sake of bitchen. they treat reviews like its yelp! you ever used the review app yelp before? its just full of entitled customers saying shitty things about some restaurants where I would typically have good service at. you could have best damn burger in the world! and I swear someone will find away to give it a one star review. its just human nature. they love complaining! so, I turned off reviews since its optional to do so upon uploading your character. why give them that space if their not gonna be constructive? its a genuine question I have for society.

    plus I already had past experience with this before on another AI website got some dumb dumb who didnt know how to use my prompts and used the whole damn script when you're not supposed to then complained my bot didnt work because they were just dumb and gave it a 1 star review. you think i wanna give them that privilege again? a second time?

    they were like BOT DO EVERYTHING ALL WHAT ONCE! like of course its not gonna work.

  7. 格鲁曼钢铁厂 ·

    这个问题我之前提了,已经改掉了,现在不打分也能留言了

  8. 大大爆肝 ·

    一般我不喜欢也不会打一星,真不行就不评价,除非是纯抄袭或者做的真的太垃圾了。

  9. giantfukker ·

    respectable. I think a lot of these reviewers are written by low patience or short attention span types who don't really know how to tinker with AI. based on what the original poster was saying. They're typically the types that write 3 word sentences and somehow manage to get all their thoughts out in just 3 words or less and they whine when they see a wall of text. so its gonna be hard to please those kinds of people anyway. they're bound to writing a bad review.

  10. giantfukker ·

    you know there was a card I didnt use at all because it was written from a perspective I couldnt see myself in so I didnt bother using the card. however, I thoughts description was fuckin hilarious! so I gave it a 5 star review and said something along the lines of I didnt use this card but the description made me laugh thank you for making it. and I doubt most people review characters like that. it still counts as a review and I was reviewing it for effort on the creation rather then my usage.